A lesbian couple shouting and arguing, representing feeling attacked in couples therapy

How to stop feeling attacked in couples therapy?

If you’ve ever thought about going to couples therapy, you might have pictured the scene in your head: the therapist sits across from you, nodding wisely, while you and your partner settle into opposite chairs. Then (and this is where the anxiety kicks in) you imagine the spotlight turning toward you, the “bad guy,” while your partner lists your “crimes.” 

It’s a common fear, and one we at GGPA hear about often. People worry that once they step into that therapy room, someone’s going to be labeled as “the problem” in the relationship. That fear is completely normal, and it’s also one of the first myths we have to dismantle if therapy is going to work. 

“…it’s not uncommon to feel attacked when you’re talking about conflict in couple therapy.”
Grazel Garcia

In reality, therapy isn’t about assigning guilt or deciding who’s right. It’s about creating a safe space to understand what’s really going on underneath all the arguments, slammed doors, and late-night silent treatments.

Over the next few sections, we’ll unpack why this “attack” feeling shows up so often, how couples therapy handles it, and what you can do to move from blame to understanding both in and out of the therapist’s office. 

Watch the full interview here!

Why Feeling Attacked in Couples Therapy Is So Common

One of the biggest misconceptions about couples therapy is that it’s a courtroom, complete with a judge (your therapist), a defendant, and a plaintiff. In reality, most couples arrive already carrying a heavy load of blame, and they’re often pointing it squarely at each other before they’ve even sat down. 

“Most couples come in to couples therapy already feeling blamed by their partner and that’s kind of what starts their negative cycle.”
Grazel Garcia
A heterosexual couple facing each other across a table and pointing fingers at each other, representing couples getting defensive in couples therapy

This “negative cycle” is exactly what couples therapy is designed to help break. It works a little like a feedback loop: one partner feels hurt, so they express it in a way that comes across as criticism; the other partner feels attacked, so they get defensive or shut down. That defensiveness can then be seen as uncaring or dismissive, which only fuels the first partner’s frustration. Round and round it goes. 

If you’ve ever been caught in this loop, you’re not alone. According to the American Association for Marriage and Family Therapy, 97% of couples say they got the help they needed from working with a marriage and family therapist. The key takeaway here is that the cycle is common, but it’s also highly treatable with the right approach. 

The tricky part is that when you walk into therapy feeling like you’ve already been “cast” as the problem, every comment from your partner can feel like further proof. Even neutral statements can land like accusations if you’re in a defensive mindset. That’s why our therapists at GGPA don’t just endlessly talk about the problem, they work to change the atmosphere in the room so it’s safe enough for both partners to speak honestly without bracing for an attack. 

Need some help to shift the atmosphere?

Looking Inward Before Looking Outward

When couples first start therapy, there’s often an unspoken hope that the therapist will “fix” the other person. It’s as if we arrive at the session with a mental list of grievances and a silent prayer: Please make them see how wrong they are. 

But one of the first, and often most surprising, shifts in couples therapy is realizing that progress begins with turning inward. This isn’t about taking all the blame, it’s about understanding the purpose behind your own behaviors and emotions before dissecting your partner’s. 

A woman sitting on steps outside looking pensive and holding a journal, representing the self-reflection that's possible through therapy
“Get to know all of the purpose of your behaviors and stay away from pointing at your partner’s behaviors, because that will get you in a negative cycle.”
Grazel Garcia

Self-awareness isn’t just nice to have; it’s a relationship-changer and often a relationship-saver. Research from the American Psychological Association has found that higher self-awareness in relationships is linked to greater long-term satisfaction and stability. In practice, that means being able to pause and ask yourself, What am I actually feeling right now? instead of What is my partner doing wrong? 

Here’s why it matters: when you identify your own underlying emotions – fear, disappointment, loneliness – you can share them without launching a criticism. Instead of “You never listen to me,” it might sound more like, “I feel shut out when I don’t get to share my thoughts.” The focus shifts from assigning fault to expressing experience, which is far less likely to trigger a defensive reaction. 

This self-awareness also gives you a clearer lens for seeing your partner’s behavior. Often, what we perceive as rejection or coldness is actually their own protective response to feeling unsafe or overwhelmed. When you can recognize that, it’s easier to meet them with curiosity instead of judgment. 

Ready to go inward? Our therapists are ready to book you in!

The Pursuer–Withdrawer Dynamic

In most couples, conflict dances to a familiar rhythm: one person pushes forward, the other pulls away. Therapists often call this the pursuer–withdrawer dynamic. 

The pursuer is the partner who moves toward conflict in the hope of creating connection, though it often comes out sounding like criticism. The withdrawer steps back, not to reject their partner, but to protect themselves from feeling unsafe or overwhelmed. 

“There’s usually a pursuer for connection and a withdrawer, not withdrawing from connection, but withdrawing from not feeling safe in the conflict that’s arising.”
Grazel Garcia

This pattern is so common that once you know about it, you start spotting it everywhere. And according to Dr. John Gottman 69% of relationship conflicts are about ongoing, unresolvable issues, which means if you don’t learn how to de-escalate, you can spend years stuck in the same exhausting loop. 

In the therapy room, Grazel works to “soften” the pursuer first. If criticism is their entry point into connection, there’s usually hurt underneath. Slowing down enough to explore that hurt – maybe disappointment, fear of being alone, or feeling invisible – transforms the conversation. 

“If there’s any hurt or pain underneath their pursuit for connection, that manifests in criticism… looking into that is going to soften their critical approach.”
Grazel Garcia

For the withdrawer, the work is different. Safety has to be rebuilt so they can step forward without fear of being attacked. This might mean slowing the pace of the conversation, validating their perspective, and setting clear boundaries around how disagreements will be handled in the session. Over time, as trust grows, they can stay engaged even in the heat of conflict. 

When both partners feel safer, conversations stop spiraling. Instead of one chasing and one retreating, both can stay present long enough to be heard, and that’s when meaningful change happens. 

Let’s start making positive changes today.

When To Park Your Defenses

Imagine a conversation with your partner where you’re both feeling tense. You’ve each got your guard up, rehearsing your next point while they’re talking. In that state, curiosity doesn’t stand a chance, and curiosity is the key to de-escalation and resolving conflicts. 

That’s why one of the key shifts in couples therapy is learning to “park” your defenses. You don’t have to throw them away (they exist for a reason) but you set them to the side for a moment so you can actually hear each other. 

“Being open, being able to park their defenses… so that they can start being curious and hearing their partner’s experiences too.”
Grazel Garcia

This is more than just good advice, it’s backed by research. Studies regularly find that active listening can significantly increase relationship satisfaction. The more we listen with curiosity instead of rebuttal, the more likely our partner is to feel understood and the less likely the conversation will spiral into attack and defense. 

A man and woman having a difficult conversation, each holding the space for each other's feelings, and connecting deeply, representing the impact of couples therapy

Curiosity is about leaning in with genuine interest: What’s going on for them right now? What’s the feeling behind their words? It’s not about agreeing with everything they say; it’s about creating space for their experience to be heard. 

In therapy, this shift often happens slowly. At first, it might just be catching yourself mid-blame and asking one gentle follow-up question instead. Over time, those small moments build a habit of seeking to understand before trying to be understood. 

When you replace blame with curiosity, you change the entire emotional climate of your conversations. Instead of escalating tension, you invite openness. Instead of fueling resentment, you create connection. 

It only feels hard when you try to go it alone. Let’s build, or rebuild, that connection together.

The Science of Attachment in the Therapy Room

Underneath all the criticism, defensiveness, and shutting down, there’s usually something much more tender at play: our need for emotional safety. This is where attachment theory comes in: the idea that the way we connect (or protect ourselves) in relationships is shaped by our early experiences and reinforced over time. 

When we’re in pain, we’re going to protect ourselves. And in our protective strategies, we might start to blame, shut down, get angry, criticize… but it makes sense if you don’t feel safe.
Grazel Garcia

In other words, your instinct to pull away or to push harder in an argument isn’t random, it’s your nervous system trying to keep you safe. The trouble is, those same protective strategies can make your partner feel less safe, creating a cycle neither of you intended. 

A couple walking through a town arm in arm, representing secure attachment in relationships

Couples with secure attachment report higher relationship satisfaction compared to those with insecure attachment patterns. That’s because when you feel secure with your partner, you’re more willing to take emotional risks like expressing your needs directly instead of hinting, or sharing your fears instead of masking them with anger. 

In therapy, building this sense of security is often the turning point. As partners begin to trust that they’ll be received with care rather than criticism, conversations can move beyond the surface-level “who’s right” debates and into the deeper, more vulnerable truths. 

Creating that safety isn’t about never disagreeing, it’s about knowing that even in disagreement, your bond holds. That knowledge gives both partners the courage to show up more honestly, which is where the real work (and healing) happens. 

Healing is possible, for both of you, together. Book a session with our experienced couples therapists today. 

Communicating Without Triggering Defenses

If there’s one skill that can completely change the temperature of a conversation, it’s learning how to share what you’re feeling without accidentally setting off your partner’s alarm bells. 

In therapy, Grazel often guides couples to experience their feelings first, to really sit with them, before putting those feelings into words. This extra step helps ensure what comes out isn’t a weapon, but an invitation. 

“[Say something like] I feel afraid to turn to you… because I love you and I don’t want to disappoint you.”
Grazel Garcia

That’s a world away from, “You never support me,” even if both are trying to express hurt. The first invites connection; the second invites defense. The difference lies in ownership: using “I” statements keeps the focus on your own experience instead of making a judgment about your partner’s character. 

And there’s good reason to trust this approach. Research has shown that using “I” statements can significantly reduce defensive reactions during conflict. It’s a huge shift for something that sounds deceptively simple. 

A couple embracing while viewing a stunning mountain scene, representing connection through couples therapy

But the thing to remember is that using scripts alone won’t work if you don’t feel the truth of what you’re saying. If you try to recite an “I” statement without connecting to the underlying emotion, it can come across as forced, or even manipulative. That’s why Grazel emphasizes reflecting with meaning: putting your feelings in context so your partner understands not just what you feel, but why

When done well, this kind of communication avoids triggering defenses and it actively builds trust. It says, “I’m letting you see me, even in my most tender places,” which invites your partner to do the same. 

Ready to learn to really see each other?

Final Thoughts

If you take nothing else from this, let it be this: couples therapy isn’t about deciding who’s the “good” partner and who’s the “bad” one. It’s about creating a safe enough space for both of you to drop your guard long enough to see, and be seen by, each other. 

That shift from blame to curiosity, from defensiveness to openness, is where the real magic happens. It’s in those moments that couples stop fighting each other and start fighting for each other. 

Yes, it can feel awkward. Yes, you might worry that you’ll be misunderstood. But with the right guidance, and a willingness to turn inward before pointing outward, the conversations that once left you feeling attacked can become the ones that bring you closer. 

Couples therapy isn’t the end of a relationship. For many, it’s the beginning of a new chapter where understanding replaces assumption, safety replaces fear, and love gets a stronger foundation. 

Top 7 takeaways:

  1. Feeling attacked in couples therapy is common and normal.  
    Many couples enter therapy already feeling blamed, which fuels a negative feedback loop of criticism and defensiveness. 
  2. Progress starts with self-awareness. 
    Turning inward to understand your own behaviors and emotions is more effective than focusing on what your partner is doing wrong. 
  3. The pursuer–withdrawer dynamic is a major driver of conflict. 
    One partner chases for connection, the other retreats for safety, and both need different de-escalation strategies. 
  4. “Parking” your defenses allows curiosity to grow. 
    Setting aside your protective walls, even briefly, opens the door to genuine understanding. 
  5. Attachment patterns shape how you handle conflict. 
    Building secure attachment in therapy fosters emotional safety and willingness to be vulnerable. 
  6. Use “I” statements to reduce defensiveness. 
    Expressing your feelings without blaming language can significantly lower the chances of conflict escalation. 
  7. Therapy is about understanding, not assigning blame. 
    The goal is creating a safe space where both partners can be heard and understood without fear of attack. 

If you’ve been holding back from seeking help because you’re afraid of being “the one in the wrong,” consider this your permission to try. You might just find that therapy gives you back something you didn’t even know you’d lost: the ability to truly hear, and be heard by, the person you love. 

Grazel Garcia Psychotherapy & Associates is one of the leading individual and couples therapy practices in the wider Los Angeles area. Specializing in treating root causes through the lens of EFT, GGPA clients can expect a warm, culturally-attuned approach to therapy. Call 323-487-9003 and schedule your free consultation today!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top